this post disproves itself. But we'll get to that in a bit.
Since everyone reading this has already read this, we shall begin from familiar territory and work our way up (or down, if you're a scrollbar-sympath) from there. Right at the beginning of his 'I have nothing to do with the Pujos' puja post, Arnab says:
Whenever I am away from Kolkata, I impose a total media ban on anything related to the Pujo, taking a leaf out of the Government of India’s Ostrichian principle that if I bury my head in the sand and censor the flow of information about a certain thing, then that thing ceases to exist any more.
The last bit of the sentence isn't entirely necessary, but it hurts the popular Bengali image to edit a dig at the government.
So anyway, like I said here, it's been the same since the e-boom hit the country: a pre-puja buildup in online communities, people asking each other if they're going 'home' (which more often than not is Calcutta), cribbing about being forced to stay away, ranting and reminiscing on blogs. Every year. It's the (Hindu?) Bengali's autumn imperative, by all available proof. Before you start shaking your head vigourously and pointing to own blog and stamping feet, let me direct you to this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this and especially this (no, I insist).
And that's just from about a quarter of my blogroll.
I wonder now. Is there much that's said that hasn't been said last year? Isn't being said on five other blogs simultaneously? Not really, no. The same rhetoric, the same nostalgia: the (fast disappearing) kaash phool , smilingcrying reunions, distant homelands, dhaaker shobdho (which I can hear as I type -- the dawn drums that rouses and summons on a grey-blue moist Saptami morning), new clothes, long sleepy dusty annual trip to the ancestral home, sepia-tinged memories of the myth of happier times.
I was writing my puja post too. And it was very personal, and beyond the first three sentences I just couldn't go on (right words are such a bitch) and I was in a state of high-middle despair. It's Saptami, dammit, when will I finish it and put it up? Which is when it occured to me that I needen't, really, you know, put up a puja post. It's not a Pujabarshiki that I publish. Sit back. Hit 'save as draft'. Relax. Is okay.
But why the automatic attempt? I'm not away from home. In fact, I think I've always been in Calcutta during puja. Maybe missed a couple growing up, but that's all (my family's not bitten by the Bong wanderlust). The comfort of shared memories, do you think? Herd mentality? Peer-pressure? Or, as I said, the creation of a pool of semi-mythical memories fed on enforced notions of how the perfect puja should be?
All this is idle conjecture, you understand, and not children of my usual stunning intellect either, because there is only so much thinking you can do in your 28th hour without sleep. I'm superwoman, but only just.
However, since we are (tangentially) on the subject, have you noticed the determined 'cultural awareness' of regional channels? Looking at the prime-slot programmes on popular cable channels, I'd say the focus was on creating (check) and sustaining (also, to a large extent, check) a flauntable ethnic identity based on an almost-identical lifestyle* made distinct with token symbols of regionality. Red-bordered white sari for the Bengali girl, for example, with a Durga Puja sequence always thrown in. For, one presumes, the allegedly too-cosmopolitan-for-their-own-good city kids.
"I know all about Bungali culchur", said a girl I once met.
"You were born and brought up here", I pointed out.
"Arrey but who mixes with Bengalis? Chhi! (Ewww!) I am knowing from Devdas and Kasauti Zindagi Kii only. They are showing all about you pipple." (Please check the links. Please)
Ah. Of course.
Not that the Bengali channels are any better. They flood you with this constructed Bangaliana of elaborate kaantha stitch kurtas and the coloured dhotis (yes, him, but also an increasing number of men who're not him), heavily embroidered saris, pora matir goina (red clay jewellery) and chunky metal 'n semi-precious stone jewellery with which I was utterly unfamiliar in life. And which have suddenly become the epitome of urban 'ethnic' Bangali - 'a', not 'e' - chic. Along with the once dreadfully unfashionable jhola .
I've been wondering if the pujo jingles and verse-advertismenst one sees in pujobarshikis can be seen as a revival of the dying culture of pujor chhoDra and pujor gaan ('Puja special' poems and music albums, as it were), but even I think that's pushing it a bit too far ;-)
------
*Which must be maintained to protect in the interests of urban consumerism. The advertisments, of course, tap into this culture of superficial difference awl the time. The potency of images that the media pieces together from life and from yearnings have been reiforced by their recurring presence in 'critically acclaimed' films. Or maybe it's a symbiotic relationship. Large families scattered all over the urban landscape returning to the big, sprawling autumn (as opposed to summer) home in a village conviniently close to Calcutta with all sorts of feudal comforts and the joys of a stylishly traditional family puja (or bits thereof) - the Shalimar puja ad jumps to mind. Or the cosy togetherness of para'r pujo complete with a romanticised version of what might equally have been harassment or pujo'r prem (love that starts during the pujas). Another inherent part, we're told, of the Bengali's Pujo. See Thumbs Up and Coke ads for proof. Not that bloggers haven't covered this aspect as well. Although the take is entirely different:
The whole hullabaloo about Durga Pujo, simply put... is this... for most bongs it's a one-week window to fix your social/love/sex life. The friendly neighborhood pujor pandal, is nothing but an exotic singles bar.
**As you can see, the Bengali non-Hindu is rather left out of the game.
------
Oh, and do I really have to explain the post-title? *grin*
Friday, September 29, 2006
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


43 comments:
Therapy. Rehab. Anything you suggest. I just want to get rid of this habit of writing enormous rambling posts. Please. Please.
it is the ok, to write long post some times.
add another link.
but what's wrong in painting the color of nostalgia? sometimes, a little overdose is not bad afterall. Even the ingredients are perfect for turning this SEVEN days into the likes of rio carnivals, only if we could have some thinking smartAsses in the tourism dept. imagine millions around the globe pouring in calcutta; the treasury wud have laughed all the way. And u r saying we r overDoing things? the goddess brings money too my deaR!!
The thing with living away from Cal and having to accept not being there during Pujo is one you come face to face with only after you have left the nest. All the time I was in Cal and spent every Pujo in the city I hardly realized what it was about pujo that I would be missing. And it is hard to put a finger on, even when I sit back and think about it. And no it is not about having a pujobarshiki or coming up with another emotionally charged sepia tinged bangali-ana ad. After a soppy cribby post last year, I refrained from doing it again. But there's something about pujo that tugs at the heartstrings. Something that makes you remember with fondness what you used to do and how things were. And then you realize that things have changed. That is where all the nostalgia stems from.
So you go out and make the most of what you have. Because ten years back if I had read my post, I wouldn't have a clue about what the hullabaloo was all about.
DD--done. I didn't think we'd be so lucky. Posts on successive days! Thanks :D
Amitava--And u r saying we r overDoing things? Tai? Koi bolechhi bolo toh? HNu hNu baba, mon diye porte hoy! ;-)
M--shei. Arnab'er post pore amaro tai mone holo. I get the feeling, though, that people think I'm railing against puja posts. Quite the contrary, I assure you. I merely wondered :-)
Long post woman but lovely.Yes yes tooooo many links. One page of your writing I can read, so many links are crazy.
Have fun. And make a few memories so you can write even more rambling posts.
Rimi devi, beautiful post! The first year I was away from home during puja was in 1997. I was very sad that year. After that I've learned to accept it. For me, puja is a social gathering and fortunately I've many friends here ('made frenship' you may say :)). So, I'm not sad anymore and am looking foward to go to the so called 'NRI pujo' tonight, tomorrow and the day after.
No comments on the length of the post, since brevity is not a friend of mine.
It must be great to have those memories. Of pujo or holi or anything else. I have stayed away from all that when I was in India, and never got into it when I was not. But I miss the memories I don't have for they anchor you to your ethnic identity. So my memoir will not have these moments of great festivities. I just remember how the city looked during pujo, that's all.
Sharodiya-r shubechha:)
Oh, btw, it might be a good idea to cross-link this post on the Calcutta blog. Just a thought.
aare didi,
ei grammar ssamar, boddo chamar!
kichu^i jaa^y na bojha :)
kemon jeno gondho pelam
taai to sesob lekhA!!
grammatically NOTHING, but someWhere sensed ur GhoRho-ToRho apotti in buying the sentiments, embedded deep inside the post. taai bollam. hneh hneh! :)
DC--thank you :-) The links were to prove a point, that all.
Panchuda--but they'll make you peel potatoes! Tar bela? :D
I'm glad you like, though.
Brazen Head--likewise. And though by currently popular parameters that should have given me a major identity crisis, I'm perfectly fine with it ;-)
R-I-P (:D)--tomakeo. Mashi'r bari jaoa holo? And I have cross-posted it on the Cal blog. Thanks for the idea.
Amitava--hoom. Awlright, I shall graciously allow myself to be pacified :-) HNeh hNeh.
ok so i wont plague u with another pujo post. not that u ever drop by to read my blog :(
j/k
went for the local pujo. quite sad really. when i have to stay away from cal, i try to stay away from things that remind me of cal. its a bit easier to bear.
not that bongs and all things bong remind me of cal - i like everyone else have my own sweet version of my beloved ... but, the sounds and the smells and the visions of pujo wafting around in the cold glasgow air, mingling with stale whiskey smells and ciggerette smoke ... makes me homesick once more.
ah, i was beginning to think the deep well of 'what's the point of it all, vitriol' was beginning to dry up.
are you familiar with the ravenous bugblatter beast of traal? ostriches are a mere nothing compared to it.
on a similar theme, there's a bit in the book where he says something about a person being able to project a power that is directly proportional to how far he is away from home. ford prefect in particular is well-versed in the technique. so, it seems, are the bongs of d-school, who floor you with their general angst at being away from 'home' at this time. i am floored several times a day. wondering whether it is worth standing up again until this whole thing passes over.
Rimi, would you believe it, my Iranian best friend says to me -
Friend: So, when is Durga Puja this year?
Me: Well, the local Bengali association is celebrating it this weekend.
Friend: Oh, we have to go. Save the date and time.
What can I say, I have adorable friends :).
I happen to like a celebration of Bangaliana, on the whole I find the idea of "the Bengali" very civilized. However, I don't care for a very narrow, homogeneous Bangaliana, which is what it has become in Cal terms, but a celebration of how truy eclectic the Bengali identity is.
I wonder how many Bengalis realize that the true carnivals of rural Bengal are not Durga Pujo (which is actually fairly subdued), but events like gaajan, sankranti, mela etc.
Hey, did you realize most of the comments on this post are from NRI Bengalis? I guess thats where nostalgia really strikes home...
Ok Rimi..or should I say Ritu....your blog made it to the Telegraph.. your URL was given as http://myownfairystories.com and your name as Ritu.
:-)
Here's the URL.
ha ha ha ha ha ha ritu!
hehehe....this post made me smile. It tells you something about the Bong presence on desi blogosphere that almost every second blog has a post on pujo!!
Yes, guilty as charged.
All Bengalis - nibashi, probashi or otherwise - feel such a irresistible urge towards Benfish, Moonmoon Sen inaugarating Ekdalia Evergreen and the girls at Maddox Square, that it manifests itself through denial, exuberance and maudlin nostalgia.
What to do? We are like this only!
E baba...bhul naam chepechey :D
Money hoy severe case of identity crisis...blog ebong blogowner - dutor-i :P
Prero--hmpfh! The last time I checked, your blog didn't exsist anymore :P And WHERE is that story you promised to send me? Huh, huh? Ekkhuni pathao! :-)
M--I'd advise you to crawl till Tuesday and thus shrewdly escape the Flooring Invasion.
I have to read that book again. Been two years since last, I think.
And finally, The Princess by any other name is still equally lethal Therefore.
Swati--you do :-)
The idea/propogated image of The Bengali is indeed rather civilized -- comparatively, at any rate, but wait till you hear some discoveries I've made recently!
Very well written - as were all the others that the Telegraph mentioned. Miss the Kolkata Pujos - but my dear Wife and I like the NRI Pujos as well......they're not quite like the real thing with the abbreviated weekend format and all, but they's fun and bring a sense of community to life - that's what it's all about, right? I'm not sure I'll agree with the disparaging remark about the Pujo pandals being singles bars - I mean, what's wrong in using the one week window to fix your social and love life (the last item on the list, I would frown upon). Great reading, nonetheless, and your blog joins GreatBong's in the select few blogs that I find time to peruse.
Notes-to-self--I do actually :-) And I'm sure it does. That's what everybody's been saying.
Arnab--oh, thank you! Ami toh kheyal-i korini. Ki bolbo, eituku claim to fame, tao bhool name aar wrong attribution :-( Kintu thanks once again.
M--shutup shutup! X-(
Szerelem--Cyberswami said exactly the same thing to me the other day. Hmm, this bears thinking about. Let's do the stat, folks :-)
Dipta--arrey, I am cheering you all on only, pipples misunderstanding my reazen for linking to nostalgic Bong puji posts. I'm wondering why only, that is awl :D
Subho--thank you very much. That last sentence is very flattering :-) However, if you read the post again, I think you'll find that the bit you refer to is a quote. I'm surprised and disappointed at The Telegraph's standard. Even if they only skimmed the post, the different font size and colour should have made it absolutely clear even to the most careless reader that the sentence was a quote.
Oh well. Do keep dropping by, though, and I hope you enjoyed your puja :-)
This whole Bong nostalgia / senti trip gets to me. I can't take so much saccharine.
If it's all about getting some, why not cut the incidentals?
the ways and the means, mr couch, its all about the ways and the means. and i'm not even bong.
I seem to keep having these totally bizarre conversations with people as Bengali as I am, who were born and brought up in Calcutta, who keep trying to pull my leg cause I'm a Bengali...until I point out that so are they, and then they seem to get annoyed.Er...what's with that?Explanations, explications, anyone?
AQC--getting some? Where did the fuck did you get that?
M--yes, well...
Hri--um, you know weird people? :D
Pretty fame-struck, eh? But Telegraph proofreading dept.-er joidi ei shochoniyo obostha hoi ki aar kora jaabey.
subho bijoya
And shubho Bijoya to you as well.
Hmmpf, am I too late to comment here!? But you know what...
Pojo means a whole lot of different things for me, a probashi bangali ever since I knew pujo.. read this http://allatonce-.blogspot.com/2006/09/durga-pujo-goes-knock-knock.html
And Cal kinda stinks at pujo times, what with the crowd and all that. I like Cal in normal times, when I can shop and hog at peace! ;)
hmmmm,,,,bujhlam,,but eto sarci hovar ki dorkar ta chilo,,,mane hoyeto bepar ta niye keu bhabeni beshi,,,but then again,,,guess the last lines seem to be sum up the whole pujo too trivially don u tink,,,mane amar post ta pore rape kore debe sheta alada bepar cos ei jinish ta niye eto bahbna chinta korte korte hoyeto ami ghumiyei portam,,,senile decay jake bole,,,but u kno it aint whinin,,maybe its another release and regret for many probashis out there,,,and maybe u kno to do something which they only hear things bout but havnt exoerienced it yet,,,tink its all human nature,,,jani khub simplistic ekta opposition dilam kintu,,,jinish ta hoyeto otoi simple,,,
Sweet.
(Now keep wondering if I said it sarcastically or otherwise.)
B--hmfph. I'd like to think I was read enough before the Telegraph mention :P
M--shubho bijoya!
Brazen Head--to you too :-)
Shirsha--nope. You're not. Everyone's welcom anytime on this blog :-)
I shall right away. and well, Cal doesn't stink, but the crowds ARE rather difficult to take.
Joy--not simplistic, no, but you've read the post with certain presuppositions. Sarcasm kothai dekhle? Whine korchhe, tai ba kothai bollam? I was merely wondering.
Aar last line bolte I suppose you mean the last quote. Ota ami boli ni. It's merely appropriate under the cirsumstances.
Dhruva--like I haven't better things to do. Today I have to oil and polish my dismembering kit.
and pray wat might the suppositions be,,,,ar whine to korchei tumi ja likhle,,,
Did you change your name to Ritu?..:-)
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1061001/asp/calcutta/story_6814987.asp
Hmmm. The Fire and the Brimstone.
Thank God I didn't write a post on Pujo / Kolkata. But then I didn't write anything. Ok well, only the one about Bombay.
How was it? Pujo, I mean. No phuchkas here but lots of fish fry.
*I'm superwoman, but only just.*
Term papers, and did you read all that stuff I gave you??
*Glasses up the nose*
Joy--moteo whine korchhe na :P Ektu mellow hoye gechhe, ei ja :-)
Abhijit--must you rub it in? :D
Udayan--shubho bijoya! And I would have loved a post on a Bombay pujo kintu! Lokjon amar wondering ke critique bhabchhe ami dekte pachhi. Sigh.
Oh well :-)
Panu--iye maane...um. I shall anon. Worry not, Woman Masquerading as Sea-annemon!
And shubho bijoya to you too :-)
thats a great small sweet sea-horse, you blind bat!!
These articles are fantastic; the information you show us is interesting for everybody and is really good written. It’s just great!! Do you want to know something more? Read it...: Head Shop, Herbal Grinders ,
Bongs, Glass Pipe. Visit us for more info at: http://www.headshopinternational.com/
Post a Comment